1. Welcome to NoFap! We have disabled new forum accounts from being registered for the time being. In the meantime, you can join our weekly accountability groups.
    Dismiss Notice

Cat person

Discussion in 'Rebooting in a Relationship' started by Deleted Account, Dec 11, 2017.

  1. This doesn't fully fit here as a thread, and mods feel free to move It, but I thought I'd get the most insightful thoughts.

    https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/12/11/cat-person/

    I read this today and thought that I would share. A lot of the comments have been, fairly, expressing sympathy with the female character (though noting her actions weren't without flaw) but I was curious about the perspective of the guy.

    I open with qualifying that a lot of what he said / did was nasty, especially the text at the end. But a lot of his behaviour seemed familiar as the behaviour of a lonely porn addict. He turns sex into a personal porno when given the chance - Possibly because he thinks that's what it's like rather than just being a creep. In fact, he seems inexperienced, and this may explain his behaviour around her not being inexperienced. On a couple of occasions he is direct and weird, as if almost demanding to be turned down - not behaviour atypical of someone who fears being turned down (it's easier to accept rejection if you think you caused it deliberately).

    I don't know. I don't want to defend a (fictional but presumably based on a real experience) person being nasty, but I saw a lot of him as a lonely person who had an idea that he was supposed to be a confident, dominant man, and didn't really know how to be one. I have never behaved like him, but I certainly remember what it was like to be an inexperienced guy, with a girl I really like, and having a totally warped idea of how I should behave with her, coupled with a terror of seeming anything but completely confident.

    Maybe I've read it wrong, but I'm curious for thoughts. I understand that it's easy to sympathise as a man, without having to experience being a woman in the position of being with a man the don't know who is in complete physical power.
     
    vibemaker likes this.
  2. Kenzi

    Kenzi Fapstronaut

    Seems like a PA to me.
    And a 20 year old, of course... Isn't going to know what to do with that
     
    Truegamer007 and Jennica like this.
  3. True. You end up with the possibility that a guy thinks porn is what sex is like, and a girl is going along with what the guy thinks.

    I shudder to think what's happening when teenagers have sex these days. What do they think they're supposed to be doing?
     
    GG2002 likes this.
  4. Kenzi

    Kenzi Fapstronaut

    I actually heard recently that lots of anxiety around teenagers having sex was that they were (boys) watching porn and when put in real life situations with girls couldn't figure it out how to get to the "money shot" where they finished.
    It was a huge stress.
    Many teen boys were having DE because of this.
    I was like... This is a thing?
    They think That is how sex ends.
    It's unrealistic.
    But. It' wwhat they are "taught"
     
    vibemaker and Jennica like this.
  5. I hadn't thought of that. But yeah i can totally imagine it.

    Kids see cars driving around all the time when growing up. So they know car chase movies are fantasy. But only a child with an unusual upbringing is exposed to a lot of real life sex.

    What do you do? Banning porn is problematic and likely impossible. More informative sex ed tends to be met with resistance. A parent can talk to their daughter, but what's to guarantee her partner will have been educated. They can talk to their son but what guarantee they'll listen (there are many more permutations of gender and outcome, I know).
     
    Pearl N. and Jennica like this.
  6. Kenzi

    Kenzi Fapstronaut

    My daughter is a teenager now and I fear for her.
    Because, reality is what is going to happen when she is with someone?
    No talking goes on in porn.
    The "money shot" is expected.
    So how do you get "up a whole body length" of a person?
    Teen boys can't figure it out, apparently.
    And stres sstress stress!!!
    How stressful!
    Have you read the dating threads?
    They don't know what they are doing!
    Of all the fetishes and strange things out there...
    Kamasutra wasn't a thing anyone cared to even fathom!
    No intimacy, or kissing...
    Your story makes some good points.
    Nobody has connections anymore and when they do, they are scaring the crap out of each other or making each other feel completely dead inside.
    Most people just use each other these days because nobody wants real connections anymore.
    I wonder how many people actually know how?
    Maybe it starts that young?
    Idk.
    Maybe that's the Real zombie apocalypse.
     
  7. True enough. Internet and social media have given us the ability to reach ever farther yet equally more superficially. I seriously doubt anyone will be on their death bed wishing they had sent one more Snapchat or posted that one photo on instagram. And I hope PAs won't just be seeking that final fap to _____. What have we become? Hopefully enough of us will hold up a mirror to the sad disconnected state we've achieved and reverse this while there's still hope and we haven't descended entirely into an apathetic stupor. Zombies indeed.
     
  8. I think both of them have some real issues. He seems lost with no clue on what to do and she seems like her only reason for even pursuing him was because she was bored with very little to do. Oddly enough the story makes the quality of sex to be the measure of the quality of the man. Robert didn't stratify her = Robert is a loser. What would this story sound like if Robert was an awkward individual but a dynamo in the sack? Would that somehow make him the ideal man for her or vice versa? Sadly, the story has us judging Robert on a superficial level and we see that the same mentality (porn) which "taught" him about how to have sex, is the same mentality which "taught' her to value him solely based on how good he was in the sack.
     
  9. True-Self

    True-Self Fapstronaut

    1,035
    1,806
    143
    @AverageBear thanks for posting a link to this story. Apparently this story has gone "viral" but I had no knowledge of it prior to you mentioning it.

    I found the story very thought provoking. More so than PMO I see Robert as someone who has been influenced by "pickup" culture. I see him as someone who has "struck" out with women using his own techniques and has taken to getting advice from the internet in order to "pull" women. This would explain (at least to me) some of his actions. The techniques he used when texting her ("let her pursue you"), attempting to "playfully" make fun of her on the date, etc. The frustrating thing for me as the reader was that these techniques seemed to work.

    When it came to the actual date I can picture him again turning to the internet on how to act, especially with the sex part. "If she comes back to your place it's on, women don't like boring sex, women like dirty talk, women like men to be dominant, women like it rough" It seemed to me like he was "testing the waters" with a lot of the ideas he was given to see how she would react.

    I agree with @Pornscars that both characters were flawed. My big issue with the Robert aside from the end of the text exchange was why was he pursuing someone so much younger? 14 years is too large of an age difference in my opinion.
    I found Margot frustrating in that she seemed to be making fun of his inexperience. She also seemed to have her own expectations about how the sex could go perhaps influenced by P. She seems surprised by the look of his body even though she can see he has a "belly". She thinks that the way he responds to her touch is not "manly". She seems disappointed with the size of his "equipment". I think it's easier to look past her actions because she is only 20 years old.

    The larger issue of the story [which I learned about from reading some of the commentaries about the story] that many women (sadly) are able to identify with is the idea of sexual consent. Margot feels like she can't say no to sex after events progress to a certain point. The unequal physical dynamics come into play when she feels that she should just "get through it" rather than risk how Robert may react to her rejection.

    So what can men do? I think this is a situation where men have to do more than what would be expected if there was a level playing field between men and women concerning physical sexual safety. If women weren't raped or sexually harassed or fear that these thing could happen to then it would be much more reasonable to expect that they should just "speak up" if than did not want to engage in a sexual situation. Until the day when we live in such a world the burden of establishing consent must fall more so on men's shoulders. Men need to do all they can to be sure that women are comfortable saying no and look for any signs that the women is not fully engaged in the sexual encounter.
     
  10. Truegamer007

    Truegamer007 Fapstronaut

    Sorry for the long post, skip to the end for my thoughts on the story.

    I can relate to this story. Me and a girl got in touch through a WhatsApp group(for Harry Potter fans) we were part of. For context, we're both 20 years old. She was a friend of a friend, but I had never met her. She was from my college, but we were doing different courses and had never met one another. We kept in touch via texting for months (yeah, months, we're both doctor who fans and share a lot of interests, so we had a lot to talk about) then eventually we decided to meet up. I had already been on NoFap for almost a month or so by then.
    I liked her, and wanted to impress her. I'm usually very social awkward. So I looked up online what to do to. Some of the videos I watched said Kino escalation was essential to get a girl to like you. Kino escalation is basically warming up a girl to your touch so something like a kiss isn't very sudden or awkward. I thought that made sense. So I decided to try it.
    When we met, I was very touchy with her. Too much, in fact. She was very uncomfortable, but I didn't pick up on it. We spoke for a few hours and then left. Then she kept giving me excuse for meeting up again. Next few times we met, was with her friends. She didn't want to meet me by herself. I never picked up on that though.
    The only reason I even know this, is she finally decided to tell me today. All this happened months ago. She also has social anxiety, and she had no idea what to do that day. And I was unable to read that I was making her very uncomfortable. Thanks to my PMO addiction I never learnt how to interact with girls, and trying to learn now, I'm making such huge mistakes. For months now, I thought our first meeting went very well... I was so wrong, and so stupid :(
    She told me today, she preferred the version of me she got to know via texting, rather than the real me, at least in the context of that meeting. Cause I suddenly seemed like a very different person. I don't think it's at all possible to get to know someone via texting or social media, you need to meet them in person. My perspective of her changed too once I actually met her. I felt less intimidated, knowing she was just another person and had her own flaws too. I had imagined a perfect person in my head.

    The timing of this story being posted is kinda crazy tbh. I do think Robert is a PMO addict, it would go a long way to explain his awkwardness and inability to pick up on social cues. I totally get why there was such a big miscommunication between the two of them.
     
    vibemaker likes this.
  11. Queen_Of_Hearts_13

    Queen_Of_Hearts_13 Fapstronaut

    842
    2,515
    143
    Holy crap. Thank you for sharing that story. It really resonated with me. My college dating experience was very much like the story in the way of not wanting to hurt a guys feelings, going through with sexual encounters I felt I couldn't say no to because things had already started, if I didn't text back get called names, etc.

    That story was very sad, and I assume a pretty accurate depiction of what hookups are like these days. Both characters had their flaws and issues, but it was just so sad to see both of them come together and have such communication issues. The disconnection and superficiality was very depressing to read. I really loved the story because of how thought provoking it was.
     
  12. What stood out to me was the disconnection these people have. They literally have two relationships—one via text and one via real life. Neither seem to reflect the other or even find a compromise between the two. The texting relationship is game of cat and mouse between the two, where they have cats that are in love.

    In reality they seem unable to read one another, have expectations that seem implied and basically don’t click as real people.

    Both characters are equally flawed—Margot is often shallow and seems interested in Robert b/c of how he makes her feel and looks at her. Robert seems unable to express himself in the flesh and has a “porn” view of sex. I mean the “girl with nice tits” line was straight out of a porn.

    It seems almost like a parable of modern communicatio. People get this expectation built up via a texting relationship (which unlike actually talking over the phone leaves out all these cues—or talking in person) that doesn’t mirror how people actually are IRL. The whole date is so awkward and clumsy. The death of modern dating. By the end of it you wonder “how many more times will each of them have this similar experience again?”
     
  13. Kenzi

    Kenzi Fapstronaut

    Yeah and yo ccan talk to people you also have no real chemistry with.
    No heat.
    And if you go in having these expectations... It's guaranteed to fail
     
    Jennica, vibemaker and Truegamer007 like this.
  14. I think the story is a great example of what's wrong with society and its view towards sex. The age old common sense wisdom of parents that "the right time is when you're in love" has been thrown out the window and for what? Sexual compatibility? What a base way to value another human being. This story represents the fruits of sex divorced from love and how even this type of behavior negatively impacts the lives of two consenting adults; as if the fact that they were consenting made their choices any less stupid or repugnant. Maybe as a society we should ask ourselves which came first? the porn or the spirit which porn was founded on aka as casual sex!

    In the past even a handshake had meaning and value. In fact it had a ton of value since it was a sign of your word; your trustworthiness. Huge contracts and deals were sometimes made on a handshake because of what it meant and communicated. Fast forward to today and no one values a handshake anymore. It means nothing because we have robbed it of it's meaning. A similar situation has happened with sex. We as a society have robbed it of it's true meaning which is to communicate love and now we're seeing the aftermath of that in failed relationships and divorce. Yet no one want's to speak up about it because they are afraid to be called prudes or enemies of "self-expression". Removing love from sex is like removing train tracks and saying your doing so to give the train the freedom of self-expression. People need to wake up. Love is not blind. Love requires boundaries.

    Seriously, fuck focusing on if Robert is a porn addict. The bigger elephant in the room is that this type of sexual encounter is being portrayed as typical and therefore normal and instead of saying WTF to that, we're squabbling over which character has the bigger problem when both are a product of the same broken system.

    You cannot love what you don't know and neither of them knew each other, so what business did either of them have in engaging in an act which purpose is to communicate love?

    Also what's with the title of the story? What does Robert being a "cat person" have anything to do with this?
     
  15. Truegamer007

    Truegamer007 Fapstronaut

  16. Hitto

    Hitto Fapstronaut

    673
    811
    93
    This thread for someone like me was good motivation and refreshing I was always trying to rush sex and get it from somewhere the last time I actually had a positive experience is from a girl I knew from college we were friends at the time but our relationship was strange because she was dating my good friend and it was weird af at one time her and my friend suggested me and him have sex with her I wasn't really with it but went along because I was so thirsty for it but it didn't really go anywhere I'm not going to describe what happened but no actual sexual intercouse took place but this is a year before we messed around and she was dating him but the one time we did start hooking up it felt very weird because I deep down I knew that she wasn't really that fun of a person to be around and she would always talk about her life problems and how the world was against her and would never be all that positive but back then I was like 22 and never had sex and still barley had any now at 28 but there were times she would just be talking and I would just try to get her to talk less and hookup the funny thing is I stopped hanging out with her because I just didn't vibe with her really on a deeper level one and also she was hooking up with a kid we knew in our circle of friends at school before me and after I stopped going with her to get lunch or hang out she went back to him and my ego was crushed but back then I realize now we were just using each other to not feel lonely and I had one other experience after that one the same yr and became fearful of not being able to have good sex with women and then my pmo skyrocketed from then on up until now sex is truly a sacred thing and I want to share it with the right person I want to know that if I felt vulnerable with this person it was gonna feel real and as a guy I thought these emotions were something I should be ashamed or are not masculine traits men should be able to have as many partners as they want you should have had done this by now but all that is bullshit and the brainwashing from society now I fully happy with abstaining until it is going to be with someone I kind share my soul with wow I rambled lol
     
    Deleted Account and Truegamer007 like this.
  17. GG2002

    GG2002 Fapstronaut

    2,007
    3,391
    143
    Me too. Its very scary.
     
  18. I don't necessarily totally disagree with you, but you're sort of imposing your personal values as if they are universal truths. For many people, the purpose of sex is sex. I don't think it's fair to say that's wrong.
     

Share This Page